Why Lift and Shift is the Best Method for Library Carpet Installations Over Packing All the Books
- William Grainger
- May 27
- 4 min read
When it comes to installing new carpet in a library, one major challenge stands out: what to do with the books. Libraries house thousands, sometimes millions, of volumes that are heavy, delicate, and often irreplaceable. The traditional approach involves packing all the books away before the carpet installation begins. This method, however, can be time-consuming, costly, and risky. An alternative approach called the lift and shift method offers a smarter, more efficient solution. This post explores why lift and shift is the best choice for library carpet installations compared to packing all the books.
What is the Lift and Shift Method?
Lift and shift involves temporarily raising or moving the bookshelves as whole units rather than removing and packing every single book. Specialized equipment and careful planning allow the shelves to be lifted or shifted aside, exposing the floor underneath for carpet installation. Once the new carpet is laid, the shelves are returned to their original positions, with all the books still on them.
This method contrasts sharply with the traditional approach where every book is removed, packed, stored, and then unpacked after the carpet work is complete.
Why Packing All the Books is Problematic
Packing all the books before carpet installation might seem like the obvious choice, but it comes with several drawbacks:
Time-consuming process: Removing thousands of books can take weeks or even months, depending on the library size.
High labor costs: Skilled staff or movers are needed to carefully pack and transport books without damage.
Risk of damage or loss: Books can be damaged by improper packing, moisture, or mishandling. Some rare or fragile volumes may be at higher risk.
Disruption to library services: The library may need to close or limit access during the packing and unpacking process, inconveniencing patrons.
Storage challenges: Finding a safe, climate-controlled storage space for packed books can be difficult and expensive.
These issues add up to a costly and stressful project for library managers and staff.
Benefits of the Lift and Shift Method
Choosing lift and shift for carpet installation offers several clear advantages:
1. Saves Time
By keeping books on the shelves, the time spent packing and unpacking is eliminated. The carpet installation can begin much sooner, reducing the overall project timeline. For example, a mid-sized public library reported cutting their carpet installation time by 40% using lift and shift compared to previous projects where books were packed.
2. Reduces Costs
Labor costs drop significantly since fewer workers are needed to handle books. There is no need for packing materials or off-site storage. The equipment used to lift or move shelves is a one-time rental or investment that pays off quickly.
3. Minimizes Risk of Damage
Books remain on the shelves, reducing handling and the chance of damage. This is especially important for rare collections or delicate materials that require special care.
4. Limits Disruption
Libraries can often remain partially open or reopen sooner since the books are not removed. Patrons can continue to access some sections, maintaining community services.
5. Improves Safety
Heavy bookshelves can be safely moved with the right equipment, reducing the risk of injury to staff or movers compared to manually handling thousands of books.
How Lift and Shift Works in Practice
The process involves several key steps:
Assessment and planning: Professionals evaluate the shelving units, floor layout, and carpet installation requirements.
Preparation: Shelves are reinforced if needed, and equipment such as hydraulic lifts, dollies, or rollers is brought in.
Lifting or shifting: Shelves are carefully raised or moved aside, often on wheeled platforms or temporary supports.
Carpet installation: Flooring contractors install the new carpet with clear access to the floor.
Returning shelves: Shelves are moved back into place and secured.
This method requires coordination between library staff, carpet installers, and equipment operators but results in a smoother project overall.
Real-World Example
A university library recently used lift and shift for a major carpet upgrade. The library had over 100,000 volumes spread across heavy wooden shelves. Instead of packing all books, the team lifted the shelves using custom-built platforms. The carpet installation was completed in two weeks, compared to the estimated six weeks if books had been packed. The library remained open with limited access during the project, and no books were damaged.
When Lift and Shift Might Not Be Suitable
While lift and shift offers many benefits, it may not work in every situation. Some factors to consider:
Shelving units must be sturdy and able to be moved safely.
The floor structure should support the lifting equipment.
Carpet installation may require special techniques if shelves cannot be moved far enough.
Extremely fragile or rare collections might still need special handling.
In these cases, a hybrid approach or traditional packing might be necessary.
Final Thoughts on Library Carpet Installation Methods
Choosing the right method for carpet installation in libraries affects cost, time, safety, and the preservation of valuable books. The lift and shift method stands out as a practical, efficient, and safer alternative to packing all the books. It reduces project duration, lowers expenses, and minimizes risk to collections.
Comments